Peer Review Process
Journal of Education Learning and Innovation (JELI) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of academic quality through a rigorous, transparent, and fair editorial process. All submitted manuscripts undergo a Double-Blind Peer Review process.
In this model, the identities of both the authors and the reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process to ensure an unbiased and objective evaluation.
1. The Review Workflow
Step 1: Initial Editorial Screening
Upon submission, the Editor-in-Chief or Managing Editor conducts an initial assessment. The manuscript will be desk-rejected if it:
-
Falls outside the journal's Focus and Scope.
-
Fails to meet the basic formatting and author guidelines.
-
Exceeds the maximum plagiarism similarity threshold (20%).
-
Lacks significant academic novelty or methodological rigor.
Step 2: Reviewer Assignment
If the manuscript passes the initial screening, the Editor will assign it to at least two independent expert reviewers who have relevant expertise in the subject area.
Step 3: Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on originality, methodological soundness, clarity of presentation, significance of findings, and relevance to the field. Reviewers are expected to provide constructive feedback to help authors improve their work.
Step 4: Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers' recommendations, the Editor will make one of the following decisions:
-
Accept: The manuscript is ready for publication without further changes.
-
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires minor revisions that can be reviewed by the Editor without a second round of external review.
-
Major Revision: The manuscript requires significant revisions and must undergo a second round of peer review.
-
Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication in JELI.
Step 5: Revision and Final Decision
Authors must submit their revised manuscript along with a Response Letter detailing how they have addressed the reviewers' and editors' comments. The final decision to publish rests entirely with the Editor.
2. Estimated Timeline
JELI strives to ensure a timely publication process. The average timeframe is as follows:
-
Initial Screening: 1–2 weeks.
-
Peer Review Process: 4–8 weeks.
-
Author Revision: 2–4 weeks.
-
Final Editorial Decision: 1–2 weeks.
-
Publication: Immediately upon acceptance and final layout.
3. Reviewer Guidelines and Responsibilities
Reviewers are the backbone of the academic publishing process. JELI reviewers are expected to:
-
Be Objective: Provide unbiased, constructive, and actionable feedback.
-
Maintain Confidentiality: Treat the manuscript as a confidential document. Reviewers must not share the manuscript or upload it to public AI tools (e.g., ChatGPT).
-
Declare Conflicts of Interest: Decline the review invitation if there is a personal, professional, or financial conflict with the authors.
-
Be Prompt: Notify the editor immediately if they cannot complete the review within the requested timeframe.
4. Ethical Considerations in Review
JELI strictly follows the COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) guidelines. Any suspected misconduct during the review process (e.g., plagiarism, data fabrication, or breach of confidentiality) will be investigated by the editorial board.


